Secondary school prizes

Winners

2019

2019

Anna Carbó Bel, Instituto Dertosa, Tortosa for "Dignified medicine, dignified death"

Anna Carbó Bel, Instituto Dertosa, Tortosa

This project considers the topic of dignified death in hospitals, exploring the attitudes of health staff towards patients with terminal conditions. Its aim is to identify how health professionals manage their patients' death, and how they accompany them on this journey, offering as much comfort as possible. This shows that medicine is limited not only by scientific progress but also by ethical principles.

 


Diana Gallardo Pérez and Mar Trinidad Fernández, Instituto Salvador Espriu, Barcelona for "The Legacy of Dr Víctor Frankenstein"

Diana Gallardo Pérez and Mar Trinidad Fernández, Instituto Salvador Espriu, Barcelona

This project stresses the need for philosophical education as a tool to reflect on scientific progress, identifying which ethical questions are the most important and considering the potential implications from an interdisciplinary perspective. It does this by focusing on the paradigmatic example offered by genetic engineering techniques: eugenics.

 


Paula Cama i Pou, Instituto de Celrà for "Cruelty to animals"

Paula Cama i Pou, Instituto de Celrà

This project analyzes the ethical implications of our relationship with other animals when our actions may cause unnecessary suffering, stress or pain. The aim is to highlight certain practices that are deeply rooted in our culture and involve the mistreatment of animals, with the objective of raising social awareness.

 


2018

2018

Marta Vecino, Institut Ribera Baixa del Prat del Llobregat, for "Science and Bioethics in Fiction"

Marta Vecino Pérez
Marta Vecino, Institut Ribera Baixa, Prat del Llobregat
 
This research analyses five pieces of science fiction that address resuscitation, and compares these depictions with the most significant scientific and bioethical developments, and to observe how scientific progress has affected the bioethical issues that these works address.
 

Laia Pérez, IES Joan Boscà de Barcelona, for "Informed consent in clinical trials with paediatric patients"

Laia Pérez i Pucurull
Laia Pérez, IES Joan Boscà, Barcelona
 
This project considers the importance of the right of paediatric patients to be informed about and to understand the treatment they will undergo, and asks whether young patients can contribute to improving their own healthcare. 
 

Maria Bretones, Col·legi Jesús Maria de Sant Andreu de Barcelona, for "Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis"

Maria Bretones Vallejo
Maria Bretones, Col·legi Jesús Maria de Sant Andreu, Barcelona
 
This projects starts from the hypothesis that Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD) is a technique that may be extremely important for human reproduction in the future, making it possible to prevent disease and even offering the possibility of artificial selection. The aim of this essay is to identify knowledge about the application, procedures, legislation, bioethical implications and future prospects of PGD.
 

2017

2017

Joana Krause, Institut Premià de Mar, for “Ethical dilemmas of a long life”

Joana Krause

This project seeks to identify the progress made by studies that investigate prolonging human life, and considers whether such achievements are really possible. It also looks at how fear of death and a desire for immortality are deeply rooted in human culture, as demonstrated by a study of three works of art. Finally, it makes a personal bioethical proposal, analyzing a range of different responses to scientific and technological progress.


Sara Clota, Instituto Canigó de Almacelles, for “Bioethics and care homes for the elderly”

Sara Clota

Her project seeks to confirm or disprove the following hypothesis: "Bioethics is seen as a complicated discipline, which is the reserve of those occupying senior professional positions, and generally ignores the existence of ethical problems in settings of direct care, and in particular in care homes. when it comes to resolving such problems, a series of values and principles are more important than medical diagnosis."


Wiam Koubiss Ajoub, Instituto Vinyes Velles, Montornès del Vallès, “Born out of necessity: The bioethics of the medicine baby”

Wiam Koubiss

The main objective of this project is to identify whether it is really ethical and legal to have a ‘medicine baby' so that it can be a donor for its ill sibling. The fact that the baby is not conscious and cannot give its consent for the use of its cells requires us to ask to what degree this is an ethical method and at what point it ceases to be so. Secondary objectives are to identify public opinion on this issue, and to find out about the bone marrow transplant process.


2016

2016

Berta Mateos Vivar of Instituto Castelló d'Empúries for “More than human? The ethical debate around neuro-improvement.”

Berta Mateos Vivar
This study seeks to address the potential social, ethical and political implications of using neuro-improvement technologies. Specifically, what arguments would justify the restriction, regulation or prohibition of the freedom of the individual in choosing to enhance his or capacities?
 
Many of the techniques of neuro-improvement or the enhancement of cognitive capacities are already freely available on the open market. This raises an urgent need for social debate to address the questions surrounding the use of such techniques, their potential, but also the risks associated with them, and the need for them to be regulated, as they could threaten such fundamental social values as autonomy, personal merit, responsibility, freedom, justice and equality.

Elena Cortina Sugrañes of Escuela Puigcerver for “Paul and ‘the Tree of Memories’. Bioethics and death”.

Elena Cortina Sugrañe

This study starts by considering the meaning of ethics and bioethics, and their application to medical care. It then goes on to analyze the concept of death, its causes and how children cope with it. Next, it discusses euthanasia, its application in different countries, and the role of living wills or advance directives documents (ADD). Finally, the study includes a practical section consisting of an activity on bioethics for secondary pupils and an activity for use in the discussing the topic of death with primary pupils.


Pere Valls Badia of Instituto Vilatzara for “Crawl & Roll.”

The author of this study has designed and constructed a device that functions as a swinging seat and as a "crawler" for children aged four with multiple disabilities. The device enables the children and their teachers to have fun and to take a break from conventional chairs, and it facilitates the basic activity of crawling, something that children with multiple functional disabilities are often unable to do. The study also considers what multiple disability is, its causes and the health problems associated with it, the educational needs of children with multiple disability and, finally, the design and construction of the "Crawl & Roll" device.


2015

2015

Marta Galisteo Garrido of Institut Llavaneres for the project: "Eugenèsia Actual ¿Cal intervenir per millorar la genètica humana?" (premis batx)

Marta Galisteo

In her analysis of eugenics, the author seeks to understand and evaluate, from a bioethical perspective, the opportunities currently provided by this practice, how it should best be applied, and how to assess the risk of discrimination. Methods used include a literature search to identify the historical background of eugenics, surveys to identify the opinions of civil society, and an interview with an expert in this area.


Mariona Asensio Pedrol and Júlia Marquès Espuga of Instituto Joaquima Pla i Farreras for the project: "La intersexualitat, el trencament d’un esquema binari" (premis batx)

Mariona Asensio Pedrol and Júlia Marquès Espuga

This essay analyzes the situation of people who cannot be clearly assigned to either gender (male or female). The authors seek to define the concept of intersexuality, to analyze the resources that bioethics offers for tackling the dilemmas that arise in these situations, and to identify the perspectives of the various professionals involved (pediatricians, gynecologists, anthropologists, experts in bioethics, etc.).  


Mireia Jaimot Pallejà of Escuela Arabell for the project: “Umbilical Cord Blood Stem Cells: business or science” (premis batx)

Mireia Jaimot Pallejà

This essay argues that the use of stem cells from umbilical cord blood is a business that is based on weighing the potential medical benefits for patients against the economic benefits for the company. The author interviewed all the Catalan hospitals with neonatal units, enabling them to analyze the differences between public and private institutions. The essay also provides a historical, scientific, legal and ethical perspective on the issue, enabling readers to form their own opinion in this regard.  


2014

2014

Beatriz de Peray, of Escola Pia Balmes, for the project "Les implicacions ètiques en el diagnòstic genètic preimplantacional".

Beatriz de Peray

This project analyzes the Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis from different perspectives, by offering ethical, legislative and technical (the procedure and the techniques used) viewpoints. The author has used a wide range of methods such as interviews, public surveys and various other documental sources, among others.


Noemí Aranda of Baix Penedès Institute for the project Un giro de 180

"A 180 degree turn" is written in the first person and relates the story of the author who has lived through the experience of cancer, more specifically Hodgkin's lymphoma, and the feelings that arise when suffering from this disease. The project is the story of survival, of learning not to give up and to keep on fighting.


Eloi Güell, of Castelló d'Empúries Institute for the project "El futur de la naturalesa humana".

"The future of the human nature" focuses on eugenics, or on the "improvement" of the human species.  This topic is progressively gathering importance, due to the progress made in science and technology and due to the serious moral dilemmas that are beginning to arise as a consequence.


2013

2013

Yousra El Kasmi, of Thos i Codina Institute in Mataró, for the project The controversy surrounding the refusal of blood transfusions

The project defines the ethical framework or guidelines used by doctors (or by officials or judges, who have to intervene as third parties when medical opinion or the criteria of the healthcare Ethical Committee is insufficient), in cases that involve blood transfusions.


Ojanta Mahmud Jorda of Marius Torres Institute in Lleida for the project Ethics applied to palliative care and the treatment of terminally ill patients

This study is an example of the convergence of science and philosophy through the analysis of how ethics apply in palliative care and in the treatment of the terminally ill. The project also aims to provide evidence that the essence of medicine, and in general any activity, has to be based on ethics and on responsibility.